Is Alpha Wave Neurofeedback Effective with Randomized Clinical Trials in Depression? A Pilot StudyChoi S.W.a · Chi S.E.b · Chung S.Y.c · Kim J.W.c · Ahn C.Y.b · Kim H.T.b
aDepartment of Industrial and Advertising Psychology, Daejeon University, Daejeon, bDepartment of Psychology, Korea University, and cHwabyung/Stress Clinic, Kyunghee University East-West Neo Medical Center, Seoul, Korea
Hyun Taek Kim, PhD
Department of Psychology and Laboratory of Behavioral Neuroscience
Korea University, No. 414, Law Bldg.(old).1,5-Ga
Anam-dong Sungbuk-ku, Seoul 136-701 (Korea)
Tel. +82 2 3290 2530, Fax +82 2 3290 2662, E-Mail email@example.com
Do you have an account?
Frontal asymmetric activation has been proposed to be the underlying mechanism for depression. Some case studies have reported that the enhancement of a relative right frontal alpha activity by an asymmetry neurofeedback training leads to improvement in depressive symptoms. In the present study, we examined whether a neurofeedback training designed to increase the relative activity of the right frontal alpha band would have an impact on symptoms of depressive subjects suffering from emotional, behavioral, and cognitive problems. Our results indicated that the asymmetry neurofeedback training increased the relative right frontal alpha power, and it remained effective even after the end of the total training sessions. In contrast to the training group, the placebo control group did not show a difference. The neurofeedback training had profound effects on emotion and cognition. First, we replicated earlier findings that enhancing the left frontal activity led to alleviation of depressive symptoms. Moreover, cognitive tests revealed that the asymmetry training improved performance of executive function tests, whereas the placebo treatment did not show improvement. We preliminarily concluded that the asymmetry training is important for controlling and regulating emotion, and it may facilitate the left frontal lobe function.
© 2010 S. Karger AG, Basel
- Gotlib IH, Ranganath C, Rosenfeld JP: Frontal EEG alpha asymmetry, depression, and cognitive functioning. Cogn Emot 1998;12:449–478.
- Henriques JB, Davidson RJ: Left frontal hypoactivation in depression. J Abnorm Psychol 1991;100:535–545.
- Johnstone T, van Reekum CM, Urry HL, Kalin NH, Davidson RJ: Failure to regulate: counterproductive recruitment of top-down prefrontal-subcortical circuitry in major depression. J Neurosci 2007;27:8877–8884.
- Dawson G, Panagiotides H, Klinger LG, Spieker S: Infants of depressed and nondepressed mothers exhibit differences in frontal brain electrical activity during the expression of negative emotions. Dev Psychol 1997;33:650–656.
- Vuga M, Fox NA, Cohn JF, George CJ, Levenstein RM, Kovacs M: Long-term stability of frontal electroencephalographic asymmetry in adults with a history of depression and controls. Int J Psychophysiol 2006;59:107–115.
- Conca A, Koppi S, Konig P, Swoboda E, Krecke N: Transcranial magnetic stimulation: a novel antidepressive strategy? Neuropsychobiology 1996;34:204–207.
- George MS, Wassermann EM, Williams WA, Callahan A, Ketter TA, Basser P, Hallett M, Post RM: Daily repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) improves mood in depression. Neuroreport 1995;6:1853–1856.
- Pascual-Leone A, Rubio B, Pallardo F, Catala MD: Rapid-rate transcranial magnetic stimulation of left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in drug-resistant depression. Lancet 1996;348:233–237.
- Rosenfeld JP, Baehr E, Baehr R, Gotlib IH, Ranganath C: Preliminary evidence that daily changes in frontal alpha asymmetry correlate with changes in affect in therapy sessions. Int J Psychophysiol 1996;23:137–141.
Baehr E, Rosenfeld JP, Baehr R: The clinical use of an alpha asymmetry biofeedback protocol in treatment of depressive disorders: two case studies. J Neurother 1998;2:12–27.
- Baehr E, Rosenfeld JP, Baehr R: Clinical use of an alpha asymmetry neurofeedback protocol in the treatment of mood disorders: follow-up study one to five years post-therapy. J Neurother 2001;4:11–17.
- Allen JJ, Harmon-Jones E, Cavender JH: Manipulation of frontal EEG asymmetry through biofeedback alters self-reported emotional responses and facial EMG. Psychophysiology 2001;38:685–693.
- Baehr E, Rosenfeld JP, Baehr R: The clinical use of an alpha asymmetry protocol in the neurofeedback treatment of depression: two case studies. J Neurother 1997;2:10–23.
Butcher JN, Graham JR, Ben-Porath YS, Tellegen A, Dahlstrom WG, Krammer B: MMPI-2 Manual for Administration, Scoring and Interpretation, ed revised. Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 2001.
Garfield SL: Psychotherapy: An Eclectic- Integrative Approach, ed 2. Mississauga, Wiley, 1995.
First MB, Spitzer RL, Gibbon M, Williams JBW: Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis I Disorders (SCID-I), Research Version. New York, Biometric Research, 1996.
- Rosenfeld JP: An EEG biofeedback protocol for affective disorders. Clin Electroencephalogr 2000;31:7–12.
- Hamilton M: A rating scale for depression. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1960;23:56–62.
- DeLongis A, Folkman S, Lazarus RS: The impact of daily stress on health and mood: psychological and social resources as mediators. J Pers Soc Psychol 1988;54:486–495.
- Ingram RE, Wisnicki KS: Assessment of positive automatic cognition. J Consult Clin Psychol 1988;56:898–902.
- Hollon SD, Kendall PC: Cognitive self-statements in depression: development of an automatic thoughts questionnaire. Cognit Ther Res 1980;4:383–395.
Beck AT, Steer RA, Brown GK: Beck Depression Inventory II: Manual. San Antonio, The Psychological Corporation, 1996.
- Baehr E, Rosenfeld JP, Baehr R, Earnest C: Comparison of two EEG asymmetry indices in depressed patients vs normal controls. Int J Psychophysiol 1998;31:89–92.
- Coan JA, Allen JJ: Frontal EEG asymmetry and the behavioral activation and inhibition systems. Psychophysiology 2003;40:106–114.
- Coan JA, Allen JJ, McKnight PE: A capability model of individual differences in frontal EEG asymmetry. Biol Psychol 2006;72:198–207.
- Rosenfeld JP, Cha G, Blair T, Gotlib IH: Operant (biofeedback) control of left-right frontal alpha power differences: potential neurotherapy for affective disorders. Biofeedback Self Regul 1995;20:241–258.
- Tomarken AJ, Davidson RJ, Wheeler RE, Kinney L: Psychometric properties of resting anterior EEG asymmetry: temporal stability and internal consistency. Psychophysiology 1992;29:576–592.
- Davidson RJ: EEG measures of cerebral asymmetry: conceptual and methodological issues. Int J Neurosci 1988;39:71–89.
- Davidson RJ: Emotion and affective style: hemispheric substrates. Psychol Sci 1992;3:39–43.
Ray WJ: The electrocortical system; in Cacippo JT, Tassinary LG (eds): Principals of Psychophysiology: Physical, Social and Inferential Elements. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1990, pp 385–412.
Shagass C: Electrical activity of the brain; in Greenfield NS, Sternback RH (eds): Handbook of Psychophysiology. New York, Rinehart & Wilson, 1972, pp 263–328.
- Affleck G, Tennen H, Urrows S, Higgins P: Person and contextual features of daily stress reactivity – Individual-differences in relations of undesirable daily events with mood disturbance and chronic pain intensity. J Pers Soc Psychol 1994;66:329–340.
- Fabes RA, Eisenberg N: Regulatory control and adults’ stress-related responses to daily life events. J Pers Soc Psychol 1997;73:1107–1117.
- Kamarck TW, Shiffman SM, Smithline L, Goodie JL, Paty JA, Gnys M, Jong JYK: Effects of task strain, social conflict, and emotional activation on ambulatory cardiovascular activity: daily life consequences of recurring stress in a multiethnic adult sample. Health Psychol 1998;17:17–29.
Zimmerman DW, Zumbo BD: Rank transformations and the power of the Student t test and Welch t test for nonnormal populations with unequal variances. Can J Exp Psychol 1993;47:523–539.
- Himadi WG, Boice R, Barlow DH: Assessment of agoraphobia. 2. Measurement of clinical change. Behav Res Ther 1986;24:321–332.
- Lynch JJ, Paskewitz DA, Orne MT: Some factors in the feedback control of human alpha rhythm. Psychosom Med 1974;36:399–410.
- Paskewitz DA, Orne MT: Visual effects on alpha feedback training. Science 1973;181:360–363.
- Davidson RJ: Anterior electrophysiological asymmetries, emotion, and depression: conceptual and methodological conundrums. Psychophysiology 1998;35:607–614.
Baehr E, Rosenfeld JP, Baehr R, Earnest C: Clinical use of an alpha asymmetry neurofeedback in the treatment of mood disorders; in Evans A, Abarbanel A (eds): Introduction to Quantitative EEG Neurofeedback. San Diego, Academic Press, 1999.
- Cohen MX, Shaver PR: Avoidant attachment and hemispheric lateralisation of the processing of attachment- and emotion-related words. Cogn Emot 2004;18:799–813.
- Vittengl JR, Clark LA, Dunn TW, Jarrett RB: Reducing relapse and recurrence in unipolar depression: a comparative meta-analysis of cognitive-behavioral therapy’s effects. J Consult Clin Psychol 2007;75:475–488.
- Hagemann D, Naumann E, Becker G, Maier S, Bartussek D: Frontal brain asymmetry and affective style: a conceptual replication. Psychophysiology 1998;35:372–388.